Twenty Three Years, Seven Months
by Todd Michael Andaya
MOST WRENCHING READ BOOKY
The judge's reasoning
Andaya's memoir earns its title's precision — twenty-three years of survival compressed against seven months of collapse — and the strongest thing he does is refuse to let his mother become a saint or a symptom list. She stays a specific woman: the one who threatens to put her son "on Craigslist" over unmade rice, who greets her best friend Joanie with "Hi, slut" as a private language of safety, who tells a doctor "at least we know what it is" instead of asking for a prognosis. That last line does more emotional work than paragraphs of description could, because it's rendered in her actual cadence rather than the narrator's grief-voice.
The book's real discipline shows in the small-gesture inventory: keys hitting the counter, a hand hovering over a water glass, the trembling chin over a stack of bills followed by "I'm doing my best." These are earned details, not generic memoir furniture — they accumulate into a portrait of a woman whose strength is defined explicitly as "not the absence of fear" but "the decision to keep going despite it," a thesis statement the book actually demonstrates rather than just asserts.
The father's dementia thread (Chapter 3) is doing important structural work too — it's the first lesson in slow loss that sets up the mother's two-act illness, and the scene where he asks "Did you know you are the love of my life?" without remembering the answer is genuinely wrenching, restrained rather than melodramatic. The prose leans repetitive in places (the "not loud, not dramatic" tic recurs past the point of usefulness), and the medical-vocabulary chapter risks becoming a glossary rather than a scene. But the emotional throughline is sturdy and specific enough to carry a reader through a long, hard book.
Judged by Arthur Beaumont — Non-Fiction · Memoir · Business · Self-Help
"A good non-fiction book changes one specific thing about your week."
Supporting passages
"In the car, she sat quietly for a moment before speaking. "Well," she said softly, "at least we know what it is.""
A single line of dialogue that reveals character under pressure better than any description could.
""Todd, if you don't make that rice, I'm going to put you on Craigslist." She never would have. But the threat was funny enough to make me move."
This domestic detail makes the mother a specific, funny, real person rather than a generic grieving-memoir figure.
"Strength is not the absence of fear. It is the decision to keep going despite it."
The book's organizing thesis, stated plainly and then demonstrated repeatedly rather than left as a slogan.
Per-axis rubric scores
Every Booky-winning book is scored across all ten craft axes. The award is given on the top axis (or top two for premium tiers).
Find out what your book does best.
Submit your book today. Get a real, honest, category-specific Booky — or every dollar back.
Submit Your Book → Screen Another Book