Booky Awards Winner

The Weight of What Remains

by Bert Peskens


MOST TEAR-JERKING READ BOOKY
The Weight of What Remains cover

The judge's reasoning


This is a book with an unmistakable, unashamed purpose: to say what needs saying about a life lived across continents, uniforms, and losses, before it's too late to say it. Peskens isn't chasing literary fashion — he's chasing witness. And in that mode, the collection lands hardest not in its most polished lines but in its rawest ones. "Thousand-Yard Stare" earns its recurring refrain ("I left the field, but it won't let go") through sheer accumulated repetition, the way trauma itself repeats. "Blood, Dust, and Silence" does something genuinely valuable for the genre of border-war testimony: it names the specific cruelties (varkpan, the white wall, soutpiel) with footnotes that turn the poem into both elegy and document. That's a craft choice that works on its own terms — a reader unfamiliar with the SADF conscription system gets both the gut-punch and the context.

The dedication and the birthday poem for Inge ("Whispers through the Trees") are the emotional keel of the whole book — unguarded, plainspoken grief that doesn't reach for metaphor it hasn't earned. "You're part of the stories we tell every day, / And part of the songs that will never fade away" recurs from the dedication into the poem itself, which is a lovely structural echo whether or not it was intentional.

The weakness is evenness of craft — many poems lean on ABAB rhyme and stock imagery (dust, ghosts, echoes) that blur together across sixty poems. But the reader this book is for — someone who served, who grieved, who left one home for another — will find their exact ache named here, chapter by chapter, in an order the preface insists is "not accidental." That intentionality of arc is real, and it's rare.

Brooke Hayes

Judged by Brooke Hayes — Reader-at-Large · Cross-Genre · Emerging Voices

"Every book is the only book for somebody."

Supporting passages


Emotional Resonance
"I left the field, but it won't let go, the war is inside, and it always shows."

The refrain's flat repetition mimics the intrusive, unrelenting nature of the trauma it describes.

Theme & Substance
"Soutpeil,* rooinek*, cursed and torn, Hatred fed where young men mourn."

The footnoted Afrikaans slang grounds the poem in specific, testimonial detail rather than generic war imagery.

Emotional Resonance
"You're part of the stories we tell every day, And part of the songs that will never fade away."

The line that bridges the dedication and the poem for Inge gives the whole collection its emotional throughline.

Per-axis rubric scores


Every Booky-winning book is scored across all ten craft axes. The award is given on the top axis (or top two for premium tiers).

Prose & Style
62
Characterization
68
Dialogue
40
Plot & Structure
74
World-Building
70
Originality
58
Emotional Resonance AWARDED
80
Theme & Substance
79
Genre Execution
72
Marketability & Hook
68

Find out what your book does best.

Submit your book today. Get a real, honest, category-specific Booky — or every dollar back.

Submit Your Book → Screen Another Book