The Staying Kind
by Rodney Henson
DEEPEST EMOTIONAL TRUTH BOOKY
Retailer link provided by the author.
The judge's reasoning
This is a book that understands the oldest romance trick there is: the ache is in what a person has trained himself not to look at. Robert Landry's whole 1994 life is a list. Dripping faucet, green poster board (not the light green), forty dollars for the jazz band, PG&E on the fifteenth. He has built a cold, orderly, loving world so that nothing in it can surprise him, and then a radio plays a dead woman's voice and the list "only sounded like it was coming from another room." That sentence did what I ask of every book: I ached for him.
The restraint is what earns it. Henson never tells us Robert is grieving. We watch him correct Erica's lyrics out loud ("Inside." "June."), pull onto the shoulder with his hazards clicking "like keeping time," and sign his name to a bill of lading that "looked like somebody else's handwriting." The quietly devastating beat is Sandra humming the chorus at the stove, flat and unknowing, "the most ordinary sound in the world... and it went into him like a nail," followed by his first lie in eighteen years, which "came out so easily that it frightened him." That is a marriage rendered with tenderness on both sides, which makes the secret hurt more.
The 1969 chapters are a separate pleasure. The Patio Lounge is built by smell and sound until you can feel the sweat on the paneling, and Erica's bottle-cap hustle is a smart meet-cute: Robert watches her hands, sees the pea, and chooses to point at the empty cap anyway. Her flicker of real surprise, "something he would spend the next fifteen months trying to see again," tells us everything about how this love will go. Details like the pencil in her hair, the Buick door with no inside handle, and the napkin note to Delbert make a woman who is both thief and gentleman, leaving even as she charms.
Judged by Vivienne Park — Romance · Women’s Fiction · Emotional Craft
"If I don’t ache for them, the book hasn’t done its job."
Supporting passages
"It was a good list. He had been carrying some version of it for twenty-four years, and he knew it the way you know the words to a song you never chose to learn."
One image sets up the whole book: a man whose devotion to routine is both genuine love and a long, careful avoidance.
"It was the most ordinary sound in the world, his wife humming at the stove, and it went into him like a nail."
Quiet devastation: the intrusion of the past lands through a domestic detail, not through melodrama.
"The smoke did not rise. It hung. It lay in soft blue layers at the height of the ceiling fans, and the fans turned lazily through it and stirred it into slow whirlpools that never went anywhere."
The Patio Lounge is rendered so physically that the reader is standing in it, which makes the 1969 half of the book immersive.
Per-axis rubric scores
Every Booky-winning book is scored across all ten craft axes. The award category comes from the top axis; a second axis at or above 75 appears as secondary recognition.
Find out what your book does best.
Submit your book today. Get a real, honest, category-specific Booky — or every dollar back.
Submit Your Book → Screen Another Book