BookyAwards · 2026
The Soulmate Strategy: My Imperfect Plan to Conquer Heartbreak and Find True Love
by Corey Seemiller
Best Quiet Devastation Booky
Takes you to this book's Amazon page.
The citation
The judge's reasoning
The Soulmate Strategy earns its Booky on Emotional Resonance because Seemiller refuses to let heartbreak be either heroic or tidy. The opening pool-party scene — drunk lesbians grinding around her lone patio chair while she texts her faraway wingwoman from Ohio — is funny and humiliating in the right proportions, and then Seemiller lands the gut-punch: she climbs into her car and screams "I'm gonna die alone!" through sobs. The tonal pivot is earned, not manufactured.
The book's emotional architecture is genuinely sophisticated. We get the slow-motion dissolution of the Runner relationship — the package with no water glass, Fun Home on the nightstand, the argument about whether texting someone "I'm interested in you" constitutes cheating — rendered with the kind of granular, uncomfortable specificity that only lived experience produces. Seemiller doesn't editorialize; she just shows Runner walking out with trash bags full of T-shirts while she stress-eats jelly beans on the phone with her mother, and the scene does all the work.
On Characterization: TikTok (leopard-print pants, spiky hair, wingwoman from afar), Mom (one-line tough love, answers on the first ring), First Love (fabric bracelets, handwritten notes tucked into backpacks) — these are real people rendered in efficient, affectionate strokes. Even Runner is complicated rather than villainous. The Sparkle/Twinkle tooth-fairy subplot — Seemiller improvising a jurisdictional excuse for getting the fairy's name wrong — is a small masterpiece of character-in-action: the solo parent improvising without her partner, grief tucked inside comedy.
From the book
Supporting passages
"The second I climbed into my car, I burst into tears, sobbing so hard my chest ached. Despite my conversation with Naked and Afraid lady, I didn't feel empowered or excited about my impending journey into singlehood. Instead, I felt more alone than when I had gotten there."
"She, a curvy woman with spiky hair who often wore hot-red lipstick and leopard-print pants, and me, a Sporty Spice with a ponytail who could only be found in workout clothes."
"I'm eating jelly beans. You can eat jelly beans and talk at the same time."
The scorecard
Per-axis rubric scores
Every Booky-winning book is scored across all ten craft axes. The award category comes from the top axis; a second axis at or above 75 appears as secondary recognition.
- Prose & Style 82
- Characterization SECONDARY RECOGNITION 84
- Dialogue 80
- Plot & Structure 78
- World-Building 75
- Originality 79
- Emotional Resonance AWARDED 85
- Theme & Substance 78
- Genre Execution 83
- Marketability & Hook 81
Scores out of 100
Find out what your book does best.
Submit your book today. Get a real, honest, category-specific Booky — or every dollar back.