Booky Awards Winner

The Finding

by r.e.joyce


BEST WORLDBUILT FANTASY BOOKY
The Finding cover

The judge's reasoning


The Finding is a gentle, wholehearted quest fantasy that knows exactly what shelf it belongs on — the tradition of talking-animal fellowship tales where transformation and found-family carry the emotional freight, and it delivers those pleasures with real sincerity. Ariah's arc from bullied, oversized filly Trinnya to the horned Princess of the valley is the book's strongest engine: the scene at the river where Tragort shows her the reflection and "the bump grew, and she knew" lands with the fairy-tale clarity this genre depends on. The bonding-of-companions sequence in the forest — Furor's mock-pompous decree ("I pronounce that this journey will be undertaken with four unusual friends... SO IT SHALL BE!") — is genuinely charming and shows a real ear for how quest-fellowship banter should feel light even while destiny looms.

The valley of Valinor itself is drawn with patient, layered geography — three mountain ranges, a sea that boxes the herd in, a plateau that becomes a prison rather than a wall. The gradual creep of the mists as a symbol of forgotten joy, and the detail that Tragort's transformation restores color to a coat that "had not seen [a sheen] in years," gives the magic system a felt cost and reward rather than treating it as decoration.

Where the book underperforms — clunky dialogue tags, telegraphed reveals, prose that tells feeling rather than dramatizing it — the Tarran chapters compensate with the sharpest material in the excerpt: the wizard's interrogation about the leopard's cold eyes is a genuinely unsettling piece of characterization, suggesting real ambition even where execution wobbles. This is a book built for readers who want comfort-quest fantasy with earnest heart, and on that axis, it delivers.

Dr. Aiyana Reyes

Judged by Dr. Aiyana Reyes — Science Fiction · Fantasy · Horror · Speculative

"A world earns belief one detail at a time."

Supporting passages


Genre Execution
"I pronounce that this journey will be undertaken with four unusual friends. The beast of the north (that's me), the lady of the woodlands, the feline horror from the east, and the ancient horse of love! SO IT SHALL BE!"

This is the fellowship-forming beat classic quest fantasy readers want, delivered with genuine comic warmth.

World-Building
"The Blackened Heights ceased being a protective wall and became an issuer of death."

A single line that turns geography into moral atmosphere, showing the valley's decline through its landscape rather than exposition.

Characterization
"Could you feel the anger in its stalk? Did the leopard change its skills because of anger? Does its hate make it stronger, wiser, or better at its deadly game?"

The wizard's probing of Tarran reveals a morally uneasy mentorship, giving the secondary hero real interior complexity.

Per-axis rubric scores


Every Booky-winning book is scored across all ten craft axes. The award is given on the top axis (or top two for premium tiers).

Prose & Style
62
Characterization
68
Dialogue
60
Plot & Structure
65
World-Building
74
Originality
58
Emotional Resonance
70
Theme & Substance
72
Genre Execution AWARDED
76
Marketability & Hook
70

Find out what your book does best.

Submit your book today. Get a real, honest, category-specific Booky — or every dollar back.

Submit Your Book → Screen Another Book