Surfacing with Hope
by Crystal Gary, MD
MOST BITTERSWEET READ BOOKY
The judge's reasoning
Plot is promises kept, and this book keeps the one that matters most: it makes you care about the people before it asks you to worry about them.
The sleeper strength is the weight of Jenny Dalton's story. The medication-swap mystery is the spine. A warfarin-laced hydrocodone bottle in the prologue, ibuprofen posing as oxycodone, bupropion where pregabalin should be. But the heart is a single mother who finds a pea-sized lump while soaking in a lavender bath, then hides her terror for the sake of her kids. The panic attack in Dr. Jennings' exam room, the way Noah lines up coasters one-two-three-four while she breaks the news, Lily's diary vow to stop fighting with her mom: these land because they're specific and unforced. The operating-room sequence is a genuine set piece. Dr. Patel watching end-tidal CO₂ climb the wrong way while every reasonable fix fails, then the pulseless arrest, reads like it was written by someone who has stood in that room. The release when Jenny wakes to find Ben and Jackson asleep at her bedside is earned.
Hidden Brook itself is a character. The Bluebird Diner, Whispering Pines, the clinic with its rotating ringtones and its wailers: the community feels lived in. Noah's WWII facts and the 'Fokker' principal's-office scene are comic gold, and Captain Bullet is a truly memorable creation.
The mystery fair-plays its clues, and Lily's red-herring suspicion of Ashton misleads without cheating. Melissa's quiet descent, rendered with sympathy, is the book's best twist.
Judged by Marcus Thorne — Thriller · Mystery · Suspense · Commercial Fiction
"Plot is promises kept."
Supporting passages
"Noah’s hands moved immediately, fingers pressing together, then apart. He glanced at the coffee table and reached for the stack of coasters, lining them up with careful precision."
A small, precise gesture that conveys a child's fear of his mother's diagnosis better than any speech could.
"He had maybe half his fur. The remaining fur was tan and brown and matted into mysterious clumps. His eyes bulged outward in two different directions. ... Despite this, he sat upright like a tiny military general."
Captain Bullet's introduction shows the book's gift for vivid, funny, affectionate detail that makes Hidden Brook feel alive.
"Not every tablet inside belonged there. He poured several into his gloved hand. Mixed among the acetaminophen were tablets that clearly didn't match."
The nightstand search pays off the pill-swap clues planted from the prologue onward and turns the mystery on Melissa.
Per-axis rubric scores
Every Booky-winning book is scored across all ten craft axes. The award category comes from the top axis; a second axis at or above 75 appears as secondary recognition.
Find out what your book does best.
Submit your book today. Get a real, honest, category-specific Booky — or every dollar back.
Submit Your Book → Screen Another Book