Booky Awards Winner

So You Want To Be An Ice Cream Flavor Inventor

by Linda Soules


BEST CONVERSATION-STARTER FOR FAMILIES BOOKY
So You Want To Be An Ice Cream Flavor Inventor cover

The judge's reasoning


Linda Soules does something genuinely difficult here: she takes a subject that could easily collapse into a listicle of fun facts and builds it into a full argument about attention as a life skill. The book's thesis — that a flavor inventor's real tool is the trained willingness to slow down and notice — threads through every section with surprising consistency. It surfaces in the jelly-bean experiment, in the advice to "let the flavor tell you what it needs," and it lands with real force in the Author's Note: "The child who learns to truly taste an ice cream is also learning to truly notice a song, a season, a person, a day." That's not filler. That's a book finding its own deeper subject.

The prose earns its keep throughout. Soules writes with a warm, unhurried rhythm that suits read-aloud perfectly, and she reaches for specificity where lesser nonfiction for kids reaches for vagueness. The mango-chili development arc — batch 1 too sweet, batch 4 detectable but mango lost, batch 7 finally singing — gives young readers a real, granular sense of creative iteration. The story of Edmond Albius, the twelve-year-old enslaved boy who taught the world to pollinate vanilla by hand, is told with economy and real weight.

Structurally the book moves from wonder to mechanics to career preparation to action in a way that carries a child forward rather than leaving them adrift. The "What You Can Do Right Now" section converts passive reading into active curiosity — exactly right for this age. This is a book that knows who it's for and respects them completely.

Brooke Hayes

Judged by Brooke Hayes — Reader-at-Large · Cross-Genre · Emerging Voices

"Every book is the only book for somebody."

Supporting passages


Theme & Substance
"The child who learns to truly taste an ice cream is also learning to truly notice a song, a season, a person, a day. Wonder, it turns out, isn't something you wait to be handed. It's something you notice your way into."

This is the book's thesis made plain — and it earns the statement because every prior section has been building toward it, making it feel discovered rather than announced.

Prose & Style
"The mango hits first (bright, tropical), then the chili arrives as a warm tingle, not a burn, then the lime finishes with clean brightness that refreshes the palate. The tasting panel's reaction to such a tasting experience says everything: a startled pause, then every spoon diving back in for a second taste."

The sentence rhythm here mimics the flavor sequence itself — a small, precise piece of craft that makes the science vivid and the creative triumph feel real to a young reader.

Theme & Substance
"Then, in 1841, a twelve-year-old boy named Edmond Albius, who was enslaved on a faraway island called Réunion, figured out how to pollinate the flower by hand. His clever trick spread around the whole world, and farmers still use it today. A kid, perhaps around your age, helped give the entire planet its favorite flavor."

The closing pivot — "perhaps around your age" — connects history to the reader's own possibility without sentimentality, and it's one of the most quietly powerful moments in the book.

Per-axis rubric scores


Every Booky-winning book is scored across all ten craft axes. The award is given on the top axis (or top two for premium tiers).

Prose & Style
86
Characterization
75
Dialogue
75
Plot & Structure
82
World-Building
85
Originality
84
Emotional Resonance
83
Theme & Substance AWARDED
88
Genre Execution
87
Marketability & Hook
86

Find out what your book does best.

Submit your book today. Get a real, honest, category-specific Booky — or every dollar back.

Submit Your Book → Screen Another Book