Booky Awards Winner

So You Want To Be A Doctor

by Linda Soules


BEST YA TONE BOOKY
So You Want To Be A Doctor cover

The judge's reasoning


So You Want To Be A Doctor knows exactly who it's for — the ten-year-old who put a bandage on a stuffed animal and meant it — and it never once forgets that reader. That dedication line is not a throwaway; it's a mission statement, and Linda Soules delivers on it across every chapter.

The genre here is the career-aspiration book for middle grades, a form that routinely condescends ("Doctors help sick people!") or overwhelms (wall-to-wall statistics). Soules does neither. She builds her book around a single governing metaphor — medicine as detective work — and returns to it with discipline, threading it through the diagnostic process, the "Day in the Life," and the qualities section. The result is a book with a spine, not just a list of facts.

What elevates it into genuine emotional territory is the willingness to hold the hard parts without softening them into nothing. "The ability to keep caring, even when caring hurts — that is what makes a doctor extraordinary" is a sentence that would land in a literary essay, let alone a children's nonfiction book. The section on walking from a devastating conversation into the next patient's room — "because the waiting room is full" — trusts young readers with real emotional weight. That trust is the book's greatest strength.

The "A Note From the Author" is unusually candid and well-written for the form, and the "What You Can Do To Prepare Right Now" section is specific and actionable in ways that will genuinely move a motivated kid. This is career nonfiction doing its job at the highest level of the category.

Brooke Hayes

Judged by Brooke Hayes — Reader-at-Large · Cross-Genre · Emerging Voices

"Every book is the only book for somebody."

Supporting passages


Genre Execution
"Being a doctor is about being the world's greatest detective. Every patient who walks through your door is a mystery. Something doesn't feel right. Something hurts. Something changed. And it is your job to ask the right questions, gather the clues, and figure out what is happening inside a body that cannot just tell you what is wrong."

This opening hook translates a complex profession into a frame that is immediately legible and exciting to a middle-grade reader — genre execution at its most purposeful.

Emotional Resonance
"The ability to keep caring, even when caring hurts — that is what makes a doctor extraordinary. Being a doctor means sometimes being with people on the hardest days of their lives — delivering news that breaks a family's heart, or losing a patient despite doing everything right. And then, sometimes just minutes later, the doctor needs to walk into the next room and be fully present for the next person who needs them."

This passage treats its young reader as emotionally capable of real complexity, earning genuine resonance rather than the sanitized version of difficulty most career books for this age offer.

Theme & Substance
"The deepest part of the promise is simpler. It is: I will not abandon you. That is what makes medicine sacred — not in a religious way, but in the older, quieter sense of the word: a thing set apart, taken seriously, held with care."

The thematic argument of the whole book — that medicine is relationship as much as science — arrives here at its most distilled and memorable form.

Per-axis rubric scores


Every Booky-winning book is scored across all ten craft axes. The award is given on the top axis (or top two for premium tiers).

Prose & Style
84
Characterization
72
Dialogue
65
Plot & Structure
80
World-Building
81
Originality
78
Emotional Resonance
85
Theme & Substance
83
Genre Execution AWARDED
86
Marketability & Hook
82

Find out what your book does best.

Submit your book today. Get a real, honest, category-specific Booky — or every dollar back.

Submit Your Book → Screen Another Book