Booky Awards Winner

So You Want To Be A Chef

by Linda Soules


BEST OPENING LINES BOOKY
So You Want To Be A Chef cover

The judge's reasoning


Linda Soules has written a career-exploration book for middle-grade readers that punches well above its category in one specific way: the prose has a real voice. This is not a rarity for adult nonfiction, but it is genuinely uncommon in the crowded field of kid-facing career books, where the default register is cheerful and flat. Soules writes in short, declarative sentences that build rhythm and then pay off — "The kitchen does not reward perfection. The kitchen rewards recovery" lands with the authority of a coaching moment, not a textbook. The opening paragraph — standing at a hot pan, tasting a sauce five times, sliding a plate across the pass — gives a child the feeling of the job before it explains a single fact.

The Emotional Resonance is equally earned. The observation that "food is how people take care of each other" is not a throwaway line; Soules walks it forward through the grandmother's soup, the father's lunch note, the dropped-off cookies, and then scales it up to the professional kitchen without losing the intimacy. The closer — "Start where every great chef started — cooking something simple for someone you love. Scrambled eggs. Burned rice. A loaf so dense it could have been a doorstop" — is warm, specific, and funny in exactly the register a ten-year-old will trust. The Famous Chefs profiles, especially Edna Lewis, do real historical and cultural work in very few sentences. This is a book that knows its reader and treats them like someone worth talking to honestly.

Brooke Hayes

Judged by Brooke Hayes — Reader-at-Large · Cross-Genre · Emerging Voices

"Every book is the only book for somebody."

Supporting passages


Prose & Style
"The kitchen does not reward perfection. The kitchen rewards recovery."

Two sentences that do the work of a paragraph — the rhythm is deliberate, the idea is specific to cooking, and it reframes failure in a way that will stick with a young reader.

Emotional Resonance
"Food is not just fuel. When you cook for people, you are saying something without words: I thought about you. I made this for you. Sit down and eat."

This passage earns its emotional weight by staying concrete and personal rather than reaching for abstraction — the three-line 'quote' inside the paragraph lands like something a real chef would actually say.

Theme & Substance
"She proved that the cooking Black communities had done for generations was not folk tradition. It was American fine dining, and it had always been."

The Edna Lewis entry delivers a genuine historical argument in two sentences, giving young readers something to actually think about rather than just a name to remember.

Per-axis rubric scores


Every Booky-winning book is scored across all ten craft axes. The award is given on the top axis (or top two for premium tiers).

Prose & Style AWARDED
87
Characterization
72
Dialogue
65
Plot & Structure
80
World-Building
82
Originality
79
Emotional Resonance
85
Theme & Substance
83
Genre Execution
84
Marketability & Hook
81

Find out what your book does best.

Submit your book today. Get a real, honest, category-specific Booky — or every dollar back.

Submit Your Book → Screen Another Book