Booky Awards Winner

See Whores

by Joie Lamar


BEST MORAL COMPLEXITY BOOKY
See Whores cover

The judge's reasoning


This book is built on its title, and it earns it. See Whores is a serial-killer thriller that keeps asking who gets seen. The killer is hunting women the city has already stopped looking at, and the story refuses to let the reader follow suit. Taysia Hart is "invisible as she was murdered," and the book spends its remaining pages making her visible: a gifted singer, a girl with a plan. When Isabel confronts the press at the hospital, "Or do you only SEE WHORES?", the title becomes a charge laid against the reader as well as the cops.

Isabel is the novel's real achievement. The prologue gives her a voice nobody else could write: "The same people who put children in cages put flowers in boxes." The mother who "had no business getting pregnant," the system as an alligator, and the baby bird crying from inside its jaws all pay off in the last pages, when she stops explaining the cry and notices that now "someone responded." Dr. Stern's slow unlearning of his own diagnoses is the kind of decency that makes this dark material bearable. Chapter 12 is the high point: Isabel treating her own grief as an investigation, then Dr. Stern leaving her coat on the chair so she can pick it up herself.

The central twist, that the monster is Isabel's half-brother and her biological father, is seeded early through Maria's dream and Rosa's letter, and it lands. The book never lets it excuse him: "Two different questions... Don't let one answer the other." Rosa's death scene and the final prison visit are where the plot's promises are kept. The dedication to survivors "who have never hurt a soul" is honoured on the page.

Marcus Thorne

Judged by Marcus Thorne — Thriller · Mystery · Suspense · Commercial Fiction

"Plot is promises kept."

Supporting passages


Theme & Substance
"Do you see young human beings with potential being viciously killed, NYPD blue? ... Or do you only SEE WHORES?"

The title becomes a public indictment, and the novel's whole argument about who the city chooses to see lands in one line.

Characterization
"The same people who put children in cages put flowers in boxes," I tell him. "My mother used to say that wildflowers give people hope."

Isabel's voice carries her intelligence, her anger and the book's central image in two sentences, and the wildflower motif pays off in the epilogue.

Emotional Resonance
"It was hanging on the chair nearest the door. He had not picked it up. He had left her something to do for herself."

A small, quiet act of respect from Dr. Stern lands harder than any of the violence, and it shows the book's emotional range.

Per-axis rubric scores


Every Booky-winning book is scored across all ten craft axes. The award category comes from the top axis; a second axis at or above 75 appears as secondary recognition.

Prose & Style
77
Characterization
82
Dialogue
78
Plot & Structure
76
World-Building
76
Originality
82
Emotional Resonance SECONDARY RECOGNITION
85
Theme & Substance AWARDED
87
Genre Execution
78
Marketability & Hook
80

Find out what your book does best.

Submit your book today. Get a real, honest, category-specific Booky — or every dollar back.

Submit Your Book → Screen Another Book