Booky Awards Winner

Sanctuary of the Lost

by Karen L West


MOST SWOONWORTHY ROMANCE BOOKY
Get the book on Amazon

Takes you to this book's Amazon page.

Sanctuary of the Lost cover

The judge's reasoning


West knows exactly what the paranormal romance / fated-mate reader wants in a first act, and she delivers it with unusual efficiency. The mate-scent thread ("Vanilla. Cherries. Fresh hay after rain") is planted early and returns with disciplined regularity, giving the opening chapters a propulsive hook without needing the mate to appear on the page yet — a patient, confident choice for a genre that often rushes the reveal. More impressive is how the book braids the romance premise to a genuine rescue-and-found-family plot. Ty isn't just brooding about a missing woman; he's running an underground railroad for abused shifter children, and that operation — Blue Stone, the bakery restored down to the espresso machine Laura doesn't know how to plug in, the clinic that treats "human or shifter, resident or visitor" — gives the mate-bond conceit real stakes instead of leaving it to carry the book alone.

The standout scene is the staged abduction at the bakery: Ty has to publicly terrorize the family he's actually saving, down to negotiating with six-year-old Tilly about how hard she's allowed to kick him ("Not in the face"). It's a clever piece of genre plotting — cruelty performed as protection — and it lands the emotional beat this genre is built on: found family earned through sacrifice, not proclamation. Tanner's "I accept you as my Alpha" landing differently than Timmy's oath, "earned instead of demanded," shows a writer thinking carefully about how her own magic system (the Alpha bond) can carry emotional freight, not just plot mechanics. The Jaxson menace is a little cartoonish, but the machinery around him works.

Dr. Aiyana Reyes

Judged by Dr. Aiyana Reyes — Science Fiction · Fantasy · Horror · Speculative

"A world earns belief one detail at a time."

Supporting passages


Genre Execution
"I opened the front door for Laura and lowered my voice. "Keep crying until we leave pack territory.""

The staged-cruelty rescue is a clever, genre-savvy plot device that turns a familiar Alpha-hero trope into real tension.

Emotional Resonance
""I accept your loyalty and place your family under my protection." The bond widened. Laura inhaled. Tanner's posture changed, the tension in his shoulders easing for the first time since I arrived."

The Alpha bond is used as an emotional payoff, not just a worldbuilding mechanic, giving the rescue scene real weight.

Per-axis rubric scores


Every Booky-winning book is scored across all ten craft axes. The award category comes from the top axis; a second axis at or above 75 appears as secondary recognition.

Prose & Style
68
Characterization
76
Dialogue
74
Plot & Structure
72
World-Building
75
Originality
60
Emotional Resonance SECONDARY RECOGNITION
78
Theme & Substance
74
Genre Execution AWARDED
79
Marketability & Hook
78

Find out what your book does best.

Submit your book today. Get a real, honest, category-specific Booky — or every dollar back.

Submit Your Book → Screen Another Book