REWIND: The Stories Behind the Songs (The Rock & Roll Triviapedia series)
by Budd Cardone
MOST TRADE-MAGAZINE-READY BOOKY
The judge's reasoning
This is a trivia book, and it knows exactly what it is. Cardone's job is to deliver a steady drip of surprising, verifiable, well-sourced music trivia in bite-sized entries, and he does that with real discipline — each entry has a hook ("Two dead presidents and a cartoon dog"), a reveal, and a kicker. The Dylan/Hendrix entry on All Along the Watchtower is a good example: it sets up the confusion of the lyric, plants the detail that even Dylan's inner circle thought his motorcycle accident had "scrambled his brain," then lands the Isaiah 21 connection as an actual payoff rather than a throwaway fact. That's the right shape for this genre — tension, reveal, button.
The book also earns its keep on substance: this isn't Wikipedia paraphrase, it's curated context (Chip Taylor being Jon Voight's brother and how Wild Thing and Angel of the Morning share DNA; the Bert Berns/Van Morrison contract dispute and the spiteful joke-song discography that resulted) delivered with enough narrative connective tissue that a reader gets actual understanding of how the music business chewed up 60s artists, not just a fact-dump.
Where it flags is craft consistency — some entries end mid-thought (the Devil With a Blue Dress entry trails off), the voice occasionally over-relies on rhetorical questions and asides ("Seriously, you can't make that stuff up") as connective tissue rather than earned transitions, and there's no larger structural arc beyond chronology-by-decade. But for what it promises on the cover — stories behind songs, delivered breezily — it delivers, entry after entry, with real research and real curatorial taste in which anecdotes to keep.
Judged by Eleanor "Nell" Whitcombe — Literary Fiction · Prose & Style
"A sentence either earns its breath or it doesn’t."
Supporting passages
"When Aretha belts out that final "chain of fools," it's not just a lament. It's a proclamation. She's not part of the chain anymore — she's the fire that melted it."
A trivia entry that closes with an actual rhetorical turn rather than just stopping — the book at its best.
"Levy sued the Beatles, or more accurately, John Lennon, over the song around the time the Beatles broke up... He owned the song along with thousands of other early rock songs that he obtained from many poor, black, and unrepresented artists."
Grounds a piece of trivia in the real economics and exploitation of the era rather than leaving it as gossip.
"Back then, almost all the bands that were charting with beach sounds were really from SoCal and living the lifestyle… except for the Rivieras. There were not SoCal beach boys, but they were a high school band from South Bend, Indiana"
Builds a vivid sense of the era's manufactured authenticity through a single well-chosen contrast.
Per-axis rubric scores
Every Booky-winning book is scored across all ten craft axes. The award category comes from the top axis; a second axis at or above 75 appears as secondary recognition.
Find out what your book does best.
Submit your book today. Get a real, honest, category-specific Booky — or every dollar back.
Submit Your Book → Screen Another Book