BookyAwards · 2026
REDACTED BLOOD
by Paige Manning
Tensest Thriller Booky
The citation
The judge's reasoning
Plot is promises kept, and Redacted Blood keeps most of the ones it makes.
The opening is a good one. Chapter One is a kitchen: star-shaped pancakes, a six-pointed one that Joseph insists "violates the pancake code," and Justin's "Article Four, Section Twelve" on burnt edges. It builds a warm, specific domestic world, and then the dispatch call about the third set of abducted twins cracks it open. That warmth gets spent later. When the yard goes silent in Chapter Five and a single yellow mitten lies in the snow, the reader has already lived in that kitchen, so the loss lands.
The central hook pays off. Two lawmen who share "a shared radar" and a face turn out to be identical twins split by a forty-year study. Joe's discovery of the St. Mary's binder, with its "Subject A — Justin" and "Subject B — Scott" labels, is the best structural beat in the book. It recasts the earlier chapters and gives the brotherhood real weight. The escalation also holds: the rescued cellar of fourteen children, the Capitol parking-garage threat, the Fletcher offer in the black SUV, the revelation of a third triplet, Karissa, and the chip-removal scene. The finale plays out on a real airfield, and Justin is physically in the cockpit.
The emotional high point is Scott's spiral. The Friday-filing reveal is the book's sharpest knife: his foster mother "was taking notes on me," and the fight that follows is earned. The line "Look at me, Coop. They want you broken" is the kind of moment these readers come for.
The story is long, and its second half leans on repeated tactical set pieces. But it never forgets what it is selling: family stakes, loyalty, and the cost of being someone's experiment.
From the book
Supporting passages
""She was taking notes on me, and she was filling out a form.""
"The last sound he remembered was Elizabeth laughing at something Joseph said. Not screaming. Not crying. Laughing."
"Two infants, wrapped in identical blue hospital blankets, stared up at him from the faded square photographs."
The scorecard
Per-axis rubric scores
Every Booky-winning book is scored across all ten craft axes. The award category comes from the top axis; a second axis at or above 75 appears as secondary recognition.
- Prose & Style 71
- Characterization 79
- Dialogue 76
- Plot & Structure 80
- World-Building 78
- Originality 82
- Emotional Resonance SECONDARY RECOGNITION 83
- Theme & Substance 80
- Genre Execution AWARDED 86
- Marketability & Hook 85
Scores out of 100
Find out what your book does best.
Submit your book today. Get a real, honest, category-specific Booky — or every dollar back.