Odds, Ends, and Other Adventures
by James A. Brandt
BEST DARK COMEDY BOOKY
The judge's reasoning
This is a collection that knows exactly who it is for: readers who want a story with a clear shape, a clear feeling, and a payoff. Brandt moves comfortably across twenty-five stories and a dozen genres without losing that contract. The comic stories commit fully. In "The Cereal Killer," Detective Spooner eats a bowl of cereal at every crime scene "to defend the victims by proxy," and the accountant-vigilante Brandon McGuffey, sentenced to teach nutrition in Captain Crunch's too-small admiral coat, is a perfectly judged joke. "Mullet Man vs. The Revenuer" earns its Alabama tall-tale register line by line, down to the sign banning "SOLICITORS, REVENUERS, OR JEHOVAH'S WITNESSES AFTER DARK." The thrillers and speculative pieces are structurally tidy: "The Scapegoat" plants its clues in a dead man's desk drawer, and "The Watch of Consequence" closes its time loop with real nerve.
The emotional high point is "I'm a Good Dog," narrated by a service dog who learns that witness, not intervention, is what the gray days require. The closing turn, "We are, both of us, found," lands cleanly. "What the Fire Remembers" and "The Long Ride Home" treat recovery honestly, with Danny walking a bag of drugs to the security desk rather than past it, and Marcus insisting the cooking is "not a cure, but a tool." "Justin and Snagglepaws" captures a sensory-sensitive child's bedtime with unusual tenderness. The prose can lean toward the declarative and sentimental, but the book's range, warmth, and craft in building to its endings make it a genuinely enjoyable, readable collection.
Judged by Eleanor "Nell" Whitcombe — Literary Fiction · Prose & Style
"A sentence either earns its breath or it doesn’t."
Supporting passages
"I do not look away. I am not asking him to be different. I am not asking him to feel better or sit up straighter or return to wherever he has gone. I am only telling him in the clearest and most honest way I have available to me, “I see you. Exactly as you are, right now, in this. I am not going anywhere. You are worth looking at.”"
The dog's narration finds a restrained, precise way to describe what presence offers someone in depression.
"Detective Hank Spooner ducked under the tape, coffee in one hand, notepad in the other, a half-eaten granola bar wrapper poking out of his coat pocket."
The comic-noir setup plays the crime-scene conventions completely straight around an absurd victim, which is exactly how the genre's humor works.
"The bracelets measured compatibility. They did not measure history. They did not care who you'd loved before, who you'd hurt, who you'd sworn never to speak to again."
The soulmate-technology premise turns into a sharp disaster-comedy once it refuses to account for grudges and ex-spouses.
Per-axis rubric scores
Every Booky-winning book is scored across all ten craft axes. The award category comes from the top axis; a second axis at or above 75 appears as secondary recognition.
Find out what your book does best.
Submit your book today. Get a real, honest, category-specific Booky — or every dollar back.
Submit Your Book → Screen Another Book