All winners
Booky Awards Winner

BookyAwards · 2026

Observations of America and My Ancestral Past

by Richard P. Sinay


Best Treatment of Family Booky

Observations of America and My Ancestral Past cover

The citation

The judge's reasoning

Sinay's book is an old-fashioned American road memoir with a real engine under the hood: a retired English teacher drives 25,000 miles in 2014 to hand his cousins a corrected family history. The stakes are small and specific, and that is why it works. He has spent a career telling students his name was Czechoslovakian; ancestry.com tells him it is Hungarian in spelling and Slovak in blood, that his paternal grandfather Andras was illegitimate, and that his maternal grandmother was too. Carrying that news from door to door gives a loose travelogue a spine.

The strongest material is the family work. The Canton chapters, with the walk through the Stark Avenue neighborhood, the shuttered Slovak Club and the cemetery visit, earn their "You Can't Go Home Again" frame. The Labak and Sinay research reports in the appendices are rare in a memoir: documented, hedged where the evidence runs out, and honest about money and loose ends ("it would take an additional 2500 dollars"). His observation that cousins range "from total non interest to total fascination" is the book's quiet thesis about what families do with their past.

The literary pilgrimages (Poe's cellar, Twain's Hartford library, Dickinson's Homestead) draw on thirty-seven years in the classroom and give the book its warmest, most informed voice. The author is at his best when he explains "The Black Cat" to a ranger who has never read it.

The rants are blunt and sometimes sweeping, but they are plainly his own, and the book never pretends otherwise. Readers of Steinbeck and Least Heat-Moon-style travelogues will find a companionable, unvarnished retired teacher with a genuine mission.

From the book

Supporting passages

Theme & Substance
"I learned that truth is not as obvious as one thinks, and as one writer put it, "Truth is a hard deer to hunt.""
Distills the book's genealogical quest into a clear thematic statement, right as the author discovers a second illegitimate grandparent.
Emotional Resonance
"Now they rest in the beautiful cemetery with the wind blowing briskly through the trees, and a calm and a peace came over me, knowing that I had come all the way home, looking down at the grave and seeing the name Sinay scrolled across the stone."
The emotional high point of the Canton chapters, where the search for roots becomes a quiet moment of arrival.
World-Building
"The Boston Tea Party was held because the colonials were tired of the taxes imposed on them by King George III. So the colonials dressed like native Americans and dumped all the tea from England destined for the colonials in Boston Harbor."
Typical of the book's teacherly voice, which turns historical sites into plain-spoken lessons for the reader.

The scorecard

Per-axis rubric scores

Every Booky-winning book is scored across all ten craft axes. The award category comes from the top axis; a second axis at or above 75 appears as secondary recognition.

  • Prose & Style 66
  • Characterization 77
  • Dialogue 62
  • Plot & Structure 70
  • World-Building SECONDARY RECOGNITION 79
  • Originality 76
  • Emotional Resonance 78
  • Theme & Substance AWARDED 80
  • Genre Execution 79
  • Marketability & Hook 76

Scores out of 100

Find out what your book does best.

Submit your book today. Get a real, honest, category-specific Booky — or every dollar back.