Not Another Swipe
by Paula Lenor Webb
MOST SLOW-BURN ROMANCE BOOKY
The judge's reasoning
This is a book that knows exactly what its readers came for and delivers it with confidence: a billionaire who hires his own emotional watchdog, a sharp-tongued librarian moonlighting as "Emma Green," and a dating-app MacGuffin (TruePair) that's clearly engineered to collide these two POV strands. The setup is pure genre pleasure — Barry's deadpan Shakespeare-quoting bodyguard shtick against Eric's puppyish billionaire chaos gives the book a comic engine that actually runs, and the Crystal-in-Cabo reveal ("Best trip ever with my love, Marco! #CaboNights") lands as the kind of satisfying, tabloid-flavored comeuppance this subgenre exists for.
The dialogue is where the book is most alive. Barry and Eric's back-and-forth has real rhythm — "You run a billion-dollar company." / "And that's exactly why I don't need the added stress of a bird." — and the running bit where Barry mangles love poetry into deadpan zingers ("Nor is it a parrot, which squawks for all time") is a genuinely fun character tic that does double duty: it characterizes Barry as guarded-but-literary while keeping scenes light without losing tension.
Claire's chapters are doing quieter, sadder work — the toothbrush left as a hint, the ache watching young couples in the library, the bruising phone call with Camila that nails a specific, ugly-familiar sibling dynamic — and that contrast between Barry's wit and Claire's loneliness is set up well for the inevitable swipe-right collision. The bones of a good rom-com are here, assembled by someone who understands genre mechanics.
Judged by Vivienne Park — Romance · Women’s Fiction · Emotional Craft
"If I don’t ache for them, the book hasn’t done its job."
Supporting passages
"There it was: an Instagram story, still active and public. Crystal, poolside in Cabo, laughing in a bikini, one arm draped possessively over the shoulders of a sun-kissed man with dark curls and a chiseled jaw."
A classic, well-timed genre beat — the accidental-tag reveal — executed with the right comic snap.
""Love is not love which alters when alteration finds, / Nor is it a parrot, which squawks for all time.""
Barry's Shakespeare-mangling tic is a distinctive, funny character signature that reveals his wit and his guardedness at once.
"Claire watched them, her smile faltering. A lump rose in her throat, heavy and suffocating."
A quiet, specific moment of longing that grounds Claire's interiority before the plot machinery kicks in.
Per-axis rubric scores
Every Booky-winning book is scored across all ten craft axes. The award category comes from the top axis; a second axis at or above 75 appears as secondary recognition.
Find out what your book does best.
Submit your book today. Get a real, honest, category-specific Booky — or every dollar back.
Submit Your Book → Screen Another Book