Booky Awards Winner

Nicks Blunder

by Tim Sawyer


BEST IN THRILLER BOOKY
Nicks Blunder cover

The judge's reasoning


Sawyer knows the machinery of the genre thriller and runs it competently. The opening flashback — the surveillance chatter between Frank and Terry giving way to the house explosion that kills a neighbor's family — is a textbook cold open, and it pays off structurally when Jesse Schild is revealed, chapters later, as the widower from that house, now coincidentally bowling in the same city where Frank runs his task force. That's the kind of convergence commercial thriller readers want: separate threads visibly being wound toward each other.

The bust sequence itself (Part III) is the book's strongest stretch — Frank's team briefing has real procedural texture (Judge Schwartz's 'loose interpretation of probable cause,' the undercover-agent reveal played for room-of-cops laughter, the radio chatter during the raid) and it moves with the brisk, plate-spinning energy of a Patterson or early Baldacci chapter. The interrogation-room scene where Frank lays out 'door number one, two, or three' for Remke is a clean, satisfying genre beat — threat, leverage, ticking clock (the beeping phone in the evidence bag) all landing at once.

The braided plotting — cartel lab, undercover cop posing as a girlfriend, a homeless witness stumbling into a gun handoff, a chance heroic intervention by a grieving widower — gives the book more moving parts than many debut thrillers attempt, and Sawyer generally keeps track of them. The prose is plain and the exposition sometimes over-explains, but the plumbing of a thriller — hooks, converging coincidences, a villain established early and menacingly (Nikitin's 'expect the unexpected' reputation) — is there and functioning.

Marcus Thorne

Judged by Marcus Thorne — Thriller · Mystery · Suspense · Commercial Fiction

"Plot is promises kept."

Supporting passages


Genre Execution
""So, to get into the agent's panties, Mr. Remke spilled the beans on who he worked for and what he did. I suspect that he inflated his importance in proportion to the boner that he had.""

The team-briefing scene has the gallows-humor camaraderie that makes police-procedural set pieces work as genre entertainment.

Plot & Structure
"Frank put a hand on Jesse's shoulder and promised him, "I won't retire until Nikitin is either dead or behind bars.""

The five-years-later payoff of the flashback promise, delivered when Jesse and Frank reunite by coincidence, shows the book's commitment to setup-and-payoff structure.

Per-axis rubric scores


Every Booky-winning book is scored across all ten craft axes. The award is given on the top axis (or top two for premium tiers).

Prose & Style
62
Characterization
68
Dialogue
65
Plot & Structure
74
World-Building
70
Originality
58
Emotional Resonance
66
Theme & Substance
60
Genre Execution AWARDED
76
Marketability & Hook
74

Find out what your book does best.

Submit your book today. Get a real, honest, category-specific Booky — or every dollar back.

Submit Your Book → Screen Another Book