Booky Awards Winner

Million Dollar Men

by Joe Salerno


BEST SLOW BURN BOOKY
Million Dollar Men cover

The judge's reasoning


Salerno knows how to open a procedural. The fire at 187 President Street is staged with real craft — Agnes Rothschild's silent roll call, the acrid smell that 'will hang in the air long after the fire is extinguished,' Angela Bergman's methodical grid work — before the book pivots hard into the three-way call between hidden principals and a volatile hired gun. That scene, with the burner phone left 'embedded in the sheetrock,' is the promise: this isn't just an arson case, it's a contract job with a client structure above the killer, and the reader is told this before the detectives even suspect it. That's a well-built dramatic irony engine, and Salerno lets it run patiently through the McMillan red herring (the fistfight over parking spots, the sealed juvenile arson record, the mysterious Post-it note reading 'McMillan fought with Janssen' appearing from an unknown hand) without over-explaining. The Post-it is a nice structural beat — someone inside the department is steering Reggie, and the reader knows it before Reggie does.

The procedural mechanics are the book's strength: formalin as an accelerant clue that widens into hospitals, funeral homes, and biotech labs; the prison-warden angle; the landlord's missing smoke detectors. Each interrogation (Donnie squirming on the sidewalk, Peter Youngblood's blunt loyalty to his crew) escalates logically. Reggie Jacobs is a well-worn but effective 'good ole boy' foil, and his friction with Bergman gives the investigation team some texture even if it leans on genre stock. This is a book that trusts its plot machinery, and by the end of this excerpt, four separate threads — arson forensics, McMillan's past, the assassin's paymasters, and MJ Fernandez's reluctant entry — are converging with purpose.

Marcus Thorne

Judged by Marcus Thorne — Thriller · Mystery · Suspense · Commercial Fiction

"Plot is promises kept."

Supporting passages


Plot & Structure
"A haunting grin spreads across the assassin's face as he silently begs them not to pay."

Plants a ticking-clock threat above the visible plot line, giving the reader information the detectives don't have yet.

Genre Execution
"McMillan fought with Janssen."

A single anonymous Post-it note that escalates the procedural mystery and hints at an inside source manipulating the investigation.

Characterization
"Every part of her aches, but it is nothing compared to the pain she has endured in her life, as the crudely tattooed green numbers on her left forearm will attest."

A quiet, specific detail that gives Agnes Rothschild weight beyond her role as neighborhood witness.

Per-axis rubric scores


Every Booky-winning book is scored across all ten craft axes. The award category comes from the top axis; a second axis at or above 75 appears as secondary recognition.

Prose & Style
72
Characterization
78
Dialogue
76
Plot & Structure AWARDED
80
World-Building
77
Originality
68
Emotional Resonance
74
Theme & Substance
70
Genre Execution SECONDARY RECOGNITION
80
Marketability & Hook
79

Find out what your book does best.

Submit your book today. Get a real, honest, category-specific Booky — or every dollar back.

Submit Your Book → Screen Another Book