BookyAwards · 2026
Love Floats
by D. W. Thompson
Best in Cozy Mystery Booky
Retailer link provided by the author.
The citation
The judge's reasoning
Love Floats knows exactly what a cozy mystery owes its reader, and it pays most of it. The opening is the strongest piece of craft here: a moonlit first float, a fog bank, an owl that sounds like "the Headless Horseman's beast," a bullet kicking up water twenty yards ahead of four kayaks, and a body in the cattails. Thompson then plants the clues that carry the back half. Katrina's "metallic clunk" against the skiff, the oversized sweatshirt on a warm night, the cigarette case with no cigarettes missing, and the donut filling that is "almost blackberry, but with a slight twang" are all fair-play details that return as payoffs.
The cozy furniture is placed with affection. Emma weeds her garden while the case simmers, a hot-dog casserole is burned, and Sam turns out to be a grill-master. Gossip circulates through the bakery, the diner and the courthouse crowd, and the tomatoes that bend in the storm while the broccoli topples are a quiet image of the book's theme about flexibility. The St. Merriam's County setting (crab pots, trotlines, River's End, Mennonite draft horses) feels lived in rather than decorative.
The cast is mostly strong. Nana Love's lucid flashes, Crab Grimes's candor over blueberry pie, and the teenage kayakers, especially Roxy's "1960 called and wants its misogyny back," give the book warmth and some bite. Emma's guilt over "shining the flashlight" on people's secrets gives the mystery a genuine emotional spine. The ghostly Maya nudges are a pleasing, slightly eerie touch.
The book is less seamless in its late reveals and in some line-level polish. The Gene Love twist is believable once the will and the pseudonymous "Suzanne Abbot" pieces land, but its foreshadowing runs thin. Overall this is a satisfying, community-rooted cozy with a memorable launch.
From the book
Supporting passages
"The flashlight beam settled on Val’s face, slack-jawed and paler than the full moon. She looked at me with wild eyes and pointed at the bank."
"Some might say the weedy persistence was admirable, well, non-gardeners perhaps. As a gardener, I knew their effort was futile."
"“Wow, Savannah, 1960 called and wants its misogyny back,” Roxy said. “Don’t let any man limit you from doing what you want. Not my brother and not your daddy either.”"
The scorecard
Per-axis rubric scores
Every Booky-winning book is scored across all ten craft axes. The award category comes from the top axis; a second axis at or above 75 appears as secondary recognition.
- Prose & Style 74
- Characterization 79
- Dialogue 77
- Plot & Structure 78
- World-Building SECONDARY RECOGNITION 82
- Originality 76
- Emotional Resonance 78
- Theme & Substance 77
- Genre Execution AWARDED 83
- Marketability & Hook 80
Scores out of 100
Find out what your book does best.
Submit your book today. Get a real, honest, category-specific Booky — or every dollar back.