BookyAwards · 2026
Lost in the Reflecting Pool: surviving narcissistic emotional abuse
by Diane Pomerantz
Most Soul-Stirring Read Booky
The citation
The judge's reasoning
A good non-fiction book changes one specific thing about your week, and this one does it twice over. The memoir's power is its double vision. Pomerantz was a trained psychologist who could see exactly what was happening to her and still could not stop it, and she doesn't spare herself that irony. The book works because the reader watches her explain things away in real time. Charles hides a toxic bowl, forgets the flowers, pockets a ceramic bag-lady angel for the hospital room, and the author lets each detail sit without editorializing until the pattern becomes undeniable.
The strongest emotional engine is Elli and Sammy. The Chemo-Shark game, with its Beanie Baby sharks "killing the cancer cells," and Charles declining to play night after night, is devastating precisely because it is so small. Sammy kicking apart the birdhouse he painted for his father's birthday, then asking "Why doesn't Daddy love us anymore?", lands harder than any of the larger betrayals. The Mr. Buttons prologue, which the book returns to with real payoff when Dr. Putman's gray tabby triggers a body-memory panic, shows structural discipline: the trauma is buried, then excavated.
The real value for readers is the Afterword, which converts memoir into usable tools: the love-bombing and mirroring stage, a list of ineffective responses (appeasing, explaining, defending, seeking understanding), and scripted phrases like "That's your opinion. That's okay." The line that holds the book together is the scripted-therapist discipline of "act with dignity." This deserves recognition for honest, hard-won emotional truth that readers in similar situations can use.
From the book
Supporting passages
""Daddy, it's important that you play. The more cancer cells we kill, the quicker Momma gets better. Come on, play with us.""
"The terrorist usurps the role of the victim in order to gain control."
"The luminous glow of the flames danced from the old stone fireplace through the dimpled glass windows, reflecting the white blanket that silently encased us in our warm, private cocoon."
The scorecard
Per-axis rubric scores
Every Booky-winning book is scored across all ten craft axes. The award category comes from the top axis; a second axis at or above 75 appears as secondary recognition.
- Prose & Style 79
- Characterization 82
- Dialogue 76
- Plot & Structure 80
- World-Building 83
- Originality 78
- Emotional Resonance AWARDED 88
- Theme & Substance SECONDARY RECOGNITION 87
- Genre Execution 86
- Marketability & Hook 84
Scores out of 100
Find out what your book does best.
Submit your book today. Get a real, honest, category-specific Booky — or every dollar back.