All winners
Booky Awards Winner

BookyAwards · 2026

If it’s I, I die, if it’s we, I’m free

by Giovanni Caruso


Best Treatment of Faith Booky

If it’s I, I die, if it’s we, I’m free cover

The citation

The judge's reasoning

A good self-help book changes one specific thing about your week, and this one hands you several. Giovanni Caruso has written a recovery memoir with a spine of practice, and the practice is what earns the award.

The central argument is stated in the title and then proven in the pages: isolation is where addiction lives, and connection is where it loses its grip. The book never leaves that claim abstract. The strongest evidence is the liquor-store chapter, where Caruso, years sober and with no crisis in sight, wakes up determined to burn down his own life. He prays a bargaining prayer in the car ("if You're there, You're going to have to figure out a way to stop me"), a friend texts "How are you doing?", and he passes four liquor stores while on the phone. That scene does more to defend the title than any slogan could.

Equally effective is the moment that opens the book's turning point: his five-year-old son sees him inebriated, and Caruso recognizes his own frightened inner child in the boy's face. It is plain, unflattering and believable.

The takeaways are specific and portable: the four anger questions (Am I being angry? Truthful? Selfish? Afraid?), the escalator image for staying in motion, the "faith moves mountains, but expect a shovel" balance, and the reframe from "Why is this happening to me?" to "What am I going to do with this?" The closing chapter condenses them into a usable field guide. Caruso refuses to claim expertise ("There isn't an original thought that comes out of my mouth"), and that humility is the book's most credible quality.

From the book

Supporting passages

Emotional Resonance
"I was driving toward the liquor store when I said a simple prayer: "God, if You're there, You're going to have to figure out a way to stop me, because I'm going to the liquor store and this recovery journey is about to be over. Help me if you can.""
A raw, specific moment of near-relapse that makes the book's thesis about connection concrete rather than rhetorical.
Theme & Substance
"Sobriety, as I understand it, is the absence of the drink or the drug. Recovery is what happens when I begin doing the work to change the person who used them as a solution."
A clean, usable distinction that carries the book's central argument about real change versus abstinence alone.
Genre Execution
"I love the saying: "God tells us that faith can move mountains, but don't be surprised if He gives you a shovel.""
Typifies the book's habit of pairing spiritual surrender with a concrete, doable instruction for the reader's week.

The scorecard

Per-axis rubric scores

Every Booky-winning book is scored across all ten craft axes. The award category comes from the top axis; a second axis at or above 75 appears as secondary recognition.

  • Prose & Style 72
  • Characterization 78
  • Dialogue 70
  • Plot & Structure 76
  • World-Building 79
  • Originality 74
  • Emotional Resonance 81
  • Theme & Substance AWARDED 83
  • Genre Execution SECONDARY RECOGNITION 82
  • Marketability & Hook 79

Scores out of 100

Find out what your book does best.

Submit your book today. Get a real, honest, category-specific Booky — or every dollar back.