Booky Awards Winner

From Dust to Love: Poems and Reflections Through Time - Refreshed Edition

by Debbie Smith


MOST HOPEFUL READ BOOKY

The judge's reasoning


This is a memoir-in-fragments where the real craft move is structural: each poem, however raw, is paired with a present-day reflection that reframes it. That pairing is where the book earns its power. "Leticia Maray" reads at first like a grief song for a lost friend, and then the reflection turns the knife gently: "she was actually part of my own soul that had been lost forever. My innocence." That reveal recontextualizes a child's fragment into something much heavier, and Smith trusts the reader to sit with it rather than over-explaining.

The throughline from "Sweeping Dust from the Floor" (written at 14-15, about entrapment) to "The Dust is Gone" (present day, "Now the broom has disappeared") is the book's real structural achievement — it's not a collection of poems so much as a documented recovery, dust as the connecting image across decades. The refrain "The song survived. / So did I" earns its repetition because the book has shown its work getting there.

The poems themselves are plain, sometimes clumsy — internal rhymes strain, meter wobbles, and a reader looking for polished verse won't find it here. But that's not really what this book is selling. It's selling testimony: a woman handing over the artifacts of her own survival, annotated by the self who lived through what the poems only gestured at. For readers of survivor memoir and faith-based healing narratives, that's the whole appeal, and "My Love," written after 25 years of marriage, lands as the payoff the earlier fragments were reaching toward.

Brooke Hayes

Judged by Brooke Hayes — Reader-at-Large · Cross-Genre · Emerging Voices

"Every book is the only book for somebody."

Supporting passages


Emotional Resonance
"The dust is gone now but I remember / What it felt like to feel so trapped"

The callback to the earlier poem shows the book's healing arc paying off in its own image system.

Theme & Substance
"At the time, I believed Leticia Maray was a real person - a friend who had been killed - but she was actually part of my own soul that had been lost forever."

The reflection reframes a childhood fragment into something devastating and clarifies the book's central project of self-witness.

Per-axis rubric scores


Every Booky-winning book is scored across all ten craft axes. The award is given on the top axis (or top two for premium tiers).

Prose & Style
62
Characterization
74
Dialogue
40
Plot & Structure
70
World-Building
58
Originality
68
Emotional Resonance AWARDED
81
Theme & Substance
79
Genre Execution
76
Marketability & Hook
70

Find out what your book does best.

Submit your book today. Get a real, honest, category-specific Booky — or every dollar back.

Submit Your Book → Screen Another Book