Flashback
by Gary A Nilsen
BEST HOOK BOOKY
The judge's reasoning
A sentence either earns its breath or it doesn't, and Nilsen's prose mostly spends rather than earns — but that is not where this manuscript wants to live, and I judge it on its own terms. What Flashback does with genuine skill is architecture: it opens with a fifth-century shipwreck, pivots to a Red Sea excavation, detonates into a Colombian hostage rescue with SEAL-team choreography, then lands the hook — a gold medallion engraved in English, buried in fourteen centuries of silt — with real patience. The reveal that the medallion belongs to a modern professor, and that a colonel is about to ask a Navy commander to assassinate Stalin using a device called a Flashback, is a clean, commercial, high-concept braid. Three narrative strands, three genres (archaeological thriller, military ops, hard-SF conspiracy) converging by chapter five is disciplined plotting for a book this early in.
The hook itself — "Commander, you're going to assassinate Josef Stalin" — is the kind of chapter-ending line that sells a series. Colonel Wells's demonstration of the empty lacquer box that becomes occupied ('the box was put there two minutes before you arrived... only that two-minute period didn't begin until after you sat down') is a nicely turned piece of hard-SF exposition — clear, logical, and it respects the reader's intelligence about paradox mechanics without over-explaining.
Where the book is plainer — dialogue that often states rather than implies, characters (Vicky, Brice) defined by competence rather than interiority — it's still functional genre furniture. This is a book built to be read fast, and it succeeds at that job.
Judged by Eleanor "Nell" Whitcombe — Literary Fiction · Prose & Style
"A sentence either earns its breath or it doesn’t."
Supporting passages
""Commander, you're going to assassinate Josef Stalin.""
A clean, high-concept chapter-ending hook that instantly reframes the entire book's stakes.
"The box was put there two minutes before you arrived. Only that two-minute period didn't begin until after you sat down."
A tidy, confident piece of hard-SF exposition that sets rules for the time-travel conceit without belaboring them.
"It read 750, meaning it was 18 karat gold. The coloring of the medallion was identical to the chain, so it appeared both were of the same purity."
Shows the patient, procedural clue-tracking that ties the archaeological and time-travel plotlines together credibly.
Per-axis rubric scores
Every Booky-winning book is scored across all ten craft axes. The award is given on the top axis (or top two for premium tiers).
Find out what your book does best.
Submit your book today. Get a real, honest, category-specific Booky — or every dollar back.
Submit Your Book → Screen Another Book