Booky Awards Winner

Excruciating

by DAVID WARD


MOST VIVID PLACE BOOKY
Excruciating cover

The judge's reasoning


Ward's greatest asset is the operating room itself — rendered with the density and specificity of someone who has actually stood inside it thousands of times. The Pyxis fingerprint trick, the color-coded drug labels, the bellows making its "Khawww-pah" Darth Vader sound, the choreography of intubation described down to the finger positions on the endotracheal tube — this is world-building in the truest genre sense: a closed, procedural environment made vivid enough that the reader feels embedded in it, the way Le Guin makes you feel embedded in a foreign ritual. That verisimilitude does real narrative work, because it's the exact machinery Matt Rix is quietly corrupting. The diversion sequence — labeling syringes, palming the tuberculin needle, injecting himself at the ankle mid-case while Mark drones on about Middle East policy — earns its horror through procedural accuracy rather than shock value.

Matt himself is the second strength. He's not a redeemable-addict cliché; Ward lets him be genuinely repellent (the internal slur-laced rage at Judy, the casual racism he tolerates in Mark) while still rooting his collapse in something legible — Jacob's death, the crash, the gun in the drawer that belonged to his father. The flashback to the crash, with Jacob asking "what's a fucking cunt" seconds before the truck is hit, is an ugly, unsentimental piece of writing that earns its gut-punch precisely because it isn't softened.

The horror-of-competence angle — professional precision as a mask for a man coming apart — is the book's most original engine, and it's executed with real specificity rather than vague dread.

Dr. Aiyana Reyes

Judged by Dr. Aiyana Reyes — Science Fiction · Fantasy · Horror · Speculative

"A world earns belief one detail at a time."

Supporting passages


World-Building
"He drew up the 2 cc of the medication in the vial into the syringe. He then peeled an orange-colored label from a tape roll of labels for that particular medication and affixed it to the syringe."

The procedural exactness of the OR routine grounds the horror in lived, specific detail rather than genre shorthand.

Characterization
"Jacob said, "Dad, what's a fucking cunt?" "DON'T EVER SAY THAT AGAIN!" he'd snapped loudly."

A brutal, unsentimental beat that makes Matt's grief and rage feel earned rather than merely stated.

Per-axis rubric scores


Every Booky-winning book is scored across all ten craft axes. The award is given on the top axis (or top two for premium tiers).

Prose & Style
74
Characterization
79
Dialogue
76
Plot & Structure
74
World-Building AWARDED
78
Originality
75
Emotional Resonance
77
Theme & Substance
76
Genre Execution
79
Marketability & Hook
76

Find out what your book does best.

Submit your book today. Get a real, honest, category-specific Booky — or every dollar back.

Submit Your Book → Screen Another Book