Booky Awards Winner

DOUBLE ON THE MURDER

by D.A. HELMER


BEST IN SUSPENSE BOOKY
DOUBLE ON THE MURDER cover

The judge's reasoning


Helmer knows exactly what shelf this book belongs on and builds every scene to earn its place there. Double On The Murder is a full-dress hardboiled noir — the drenched Hollywood Boulevard neon, the corrupt Commissioner, the honest cops who owe the PI favors, the femme fatale who licks her upper lip like it's a weapon — and it plays the form straight and confident rather than winking at it.

The mechanics are where the book really earns its keep. Joe Stone doesn't stumble into a mystery; he's handed a puzzle piece by piece that a genre reader can actually work: filed-off serial numbers on three separate guns, one spent round left in an otherwise empty cylinder each time, a suicide note wiped clean of prints, a post-mortem gunshot on a body already strangled elsewhere. When Woodhouse tells Stone "Same as the Moe Merrit case," it lands because Helmer planted that case history two chapters earlier at the courthouse — a serial pattern disguised as three unrelated suicides. That's a promise-and-payoff structure a mystery reader will recognize and respect.

The escalation is well-timed too: client walks in confused (chapter one), double murder discovered (chapter two), and then the gut-punch of Arnie Bender's body under the sheet in the rain — a death that actually costs the narrator something, and reads as the emotional hinge of the opening act. Mya Regis's entrance, all silk gloves and controlled hostility, is a genre-perfect femme fatale beat, right down to noticing the diamond earring and saying nothing about it. Fans of Chandler-adjacent noir mystery will find the machinery here does its job.

Marcus Thorne

Judged by Marcus Thorne — Thriller · Mystery · Suspense · Commercial Fiction

"Plot is promises kept."

Supporting passages


Genre Execution
"The serial numb ers were filed off both weapons, and get this, her gunshot was post -mortem."

The recurring filed-serial-number, single-spent-round gun signature ties three separate deaths into one conspiracy — classic noir plotting mechanics done with care.

Plot & Structure
"When I lifted the sheet, Arnie Bender's head laid there in blood and water. His eyes were open and clear. He had been shot dead -center forehead."

The murder of Stone's own associate mid-investigation raises the stakes and gives the case personal weight beyond procedure.

Characterization
""I don't believe in coincidences, Mr. Stone," she said with a warm smile."

Mya Regis's controlled, needling dialogue establishes her as a genuine genre femme fatale rather than a flat archetype.

Per-axis rubric scores


Every Booky-winning book is scored across all ten craft axes. The award is given on the top axis (or top two for premium tiers).

Prose & Style
72
Characterization
76
Dialogue
74
Plot & Structure
80
World-Building
78
Originality
65
Emotional Resonance
72
Theme & Substance
68
Genre Execution AWARDED
84
Marketability & Hook
80

Find out what your book does best.

Submit your book today. Get a real, honest, category-specific Booky — or every dollar back.

Submit Your Book → Screen Another Book