Booky Awards Winner

Dirty South

by Andy Hageman


MOST EFFORTLESS PROSE BOOKY
Dirty South cover

The judge's reasoning


Hageman's real skill is the joke that arrives with a limp already built in. "I arrived with a leap of faith to dismantle my spine in installments" sets the register on page one and he never drops it: William the Conqueror gets a crown, Hageman gets "a forty-year suspended sentence" from his own vertebrae. That conceit — the spine as a patient, methodical assailant handing down sentences it will collect on decades later — is the book's actual structural spine (sorry), and it's a genuinely clever organizing device for a memoir that otherwise sprawls across cricket pitches, hotel kitchens, golf clubs, and Albuquerque bedrooms.

The voice is dry, self-mocking, and specific rather than generically wry — he doesn't just say the hospital food was bad, he gives you "grey mush that claimed to be shepherd's pie" and the diagnosis that "you come in for a broken back, you stay for the malnutrition." The Diazepam discography scene in Chapter Two is the book's high point: the tension between his bravado ("I had a history with pain") and the doctor's flat, unbothered professionalism ("Her face didn't change; not even a flicker") plays as both comedy and a small, honest confession about what pain actually does to a person's mouth and dignity.

What holds it back from a higher ceiling is that the jokes sometimes do the emotional work the narrative should be doing — Gran's intervention and the wedding-day beach carry are genuinely tender beats that get walked past quickly on the way to the next punchline. But for a reader who wants the black comedy of a body falling apart narrated by someone who refuses to be solemn about it, this delivers exactly what it promises, chapter after chapter.

Arthur Beaumont

Judged by Arthur Beaumont — Non-Fiction · Memoir · Business · Self-Help

"A good non-fiction book changes one specific thing about your week."

Supporting passages


Prose & Style
"He arrived with an army to dismantle a nation; I arrived with a leap of faith to dismantle my spine in installments."

The William the Conqueror conceit that frames the whole opening is sharp, controlled, and does real structural work beyond being a one-liner.

Genre Execution
"That hurts like a bitch! Oh, you cunt!’ ... Her face didn't change; not even a flicker."

The discography scene delivers exactly the blend of self-deprecating comedy and physical dread the book is selling.

Characterization
"‘You should never have been in that place,’ she said, with the kind of authority that made specialists look like amateurs."

A single line establishes the grandmother as a fully credible, formidable presence without extended exposition.

Per-axis rubric scores


Every Booky-winning book is scored across all ten craft axes. The award is given on the top axis (or top two for premium tiers).

Prose & Style AWARDED
82
Characterization
74
Dialogue
70
Plot & Structure
66
World-Building
76
Originality
75
Emotional Resonance
66
Theme & Substance
60
Genre Execution
80
Marketability & Hook
78

Find out what your book does best.

Submit your book today. Get a real, honest, category-specific Booky — or every dollar back.

Submit Your Book → Screen Another Book