All winners
Booky Awards Winner

BookyAwards · 2026

Confessions of an English Teacher Book 7

by Richard Sinay


Best Treatment of Class Booky

Confessions of an English Teacher Book 7 cover

The citation

The judge's reasoning

This is a book with a mission, and Sinay never lets the reader lose sight of it. Across twenty-four chapters he argues one clear proposition: that average and below-average students are being failed by one-size-fits-all textbooks, and that literacy grows fastest through what he calls the Step-Ladder Approach, reading just above a student's instructional level and drawn from their own culture. That argument is built from thirty-seven years in the classroom, and it shows.

The book's most persuasive material is autobiographical. Chapter 7 lists all thirty-two assigned works from his own 1962–66 high school years and then dismantles them, observing that apart from The Pearl every one sat above a ninth grader's reading level. The comic anecdote of the English teacher assigned to teach Chemistry, who read a novel while a sophomore read the textbook aloud, is exactly the kind of lived evidence that makes an argument stick. So is the confession in Chapter 5, where he admits he gave students a flattering justification for reading The Scarlet Letter while knowing it was out of their reach.

The practical chapters deliver on the promise. The Catcher in the Rye thesis-building walkthrough, the Blake "Lamb"/"Tyger" lesson (complete with the "Who's your daddy?" classroom laugh), and the insistence that a Shakespeare play take weeks rather than a semester are concrete enough for a working teacher to use Monday morning. The culturally organized reading lists in Chapters 19–23 extend the thesis into usable curricula.

The book repeats itself and some chapters are loosely edited, but its conviction, specificity and usefulness to its intended reader earn this recognition for substance.

From the book

Supporting passages

Theme & Substance
"Aside from the book The Pearl by John Steinbeck, every one of these novels is above the reading level of a freshman reading at 9.0 or the ninth-grade level."
Sinay turns his own high school reading list into concrete evidence for his central claim that assigned literature routinely outruns students' linguistic ability.
Genre Execution
"I would jokingly add that the speaker is asking an important question: “Who’s your daddy?” This remark drew howls of laughter because the students used that phrase during the social time when I was teaching the poem."
A specific, usable classroom moment that shows the method (identify the speaker, then draft the thesis together) working with real students.
Theme & Substance
"When the curriculum is the standard classics of dead European men, it sends a subconscious message to a diverse student body. It says that “your story isn’t a part of the important human narrative.”"
This crystallizes the cultural-relevance argument that drives the whole book, and ties it to what he actually saw in his classrooms.

The scorecard

Per-axis rubric scores

Every Booky-winning book is scored across all ten craft axes. The award category comes from the top axis; a second axis at or above 75 appears as secondary recognition.

  • Prose & Style 66
  • Characterization 72
  • Dialogue 64
  • Plot & Structure 73
  • World-Building 76
  • Originality 76
  • Emotional Resonance 70
  • Theme & Substance AWARDED 82
  • Genre Execution SECONDARY RECOGNITION 80
  • Marketability & Hook 79

Scores out of 100

Find out what your book does best.

Submit your book today. Get a real, honest, category-specific Booky — or every dollar back.