BookyAwards · 2026
Confessions of an English Teacher Book 2
by Richard Sinay
Best Treatment of Emotion Booky
The citation
The judge's reasoning
Sinay's book is built on a conviction most education manuals only gesture at: that English teaching fails less from bad teachers than from closed doors. He opens with Parker Palmer's line about teaching as the most privatized of the professions and tests it against thirty-five years in high school classrooms and twenty-eight in community colleges. The substance is specific and practical. He argues that vocabulary belongs inside the sentence of the novel being read, not on a Friday matching test. He contends that grammar taught apart from a student's own drafts does not transfer to writing, and he cites Hillocks's meta-analysis and Patricia Dunn to support it. He says a placement grammar test measures a student's grammar rather than her writing, and he proposes a writing sample or a reading test instead. Each claim comes with the tool for acting on it: the San Diego Quick Assessment for matching students to books, the Nelson-Denny for measuring gains, rubric calibration across a department.
The lived sense of the profession is the book's other strength. The senior poetry-paper standoff is the best scene in it: three teachers, one weeping, a department chair sprinting to the principal's office, and Sinay's pitch for an MLA argumentative paper that the principal grants "for one more year." The department meeting where fifteen teachers grade the same essay from A to F, one calling it "too pretentious," shows the inconsistency he argues against better than any rubric could. The new teacher in the book room asking where Huckleberry Finn is, with no one having told her the course order, makes his case for shared outlines and lesson plans.
The prose is plain and repetitive, and the tone sometimes turns sharp toward colleagues. But for its audience of department chairs, new teachers, and administrators, this is a candid, experience-backed set of hallmarks worth arguing with, and that earns the recognition.
From the book
Supporting passages
"The question important to teaching writing is whether we are assigning or teaching writing. Teaching writing is coaxing the students through the process of writing a paper."
"Some of us gave the paper an “A,” while some gave it a “B,” and others gave it a “C.” One teacher arrived at the “D” level, but the most interesting was a rather arrogant teacher who assigned the paper an “F.”"
"A course outline is a contract, and the contract is something that both sides need to fulfill."
The scorecard
Per-axis rubric scores
Every Booky-winning book is scored across all ten craft axes. The award category comes from the top axis; a second axis at or above 75 appears as secondary recognition.
- Prose & Style 66
- Characterization 70
- Dialogue 60
- Plot & Structure 76
- World-Building 78
- Originality 75
- Emotional Resonance 68
- Theme & Substance AWARDED 80
- Genre Execution SECONDARY RECOGNITION 79
- Marketability & Hook 77
Scores out of 100
Find out what your book does best.
Submit your book today. Get a real, honest, category-specific Booky — or every dollar back.