Bones of Black Saints
by Alex Charns
BEST WORKPLACE SETTING BOOKY
The judge's reasoning
Charns writes what he clearly knows cold — the courtroom as ecosystem, not just setting — and it's the book's strongest asset. The procedural detail is granular and alive: the sunk prosecution table and raised defense table as a literal, almost absurdist metaphor for tilted advantage; the N.C. Eyewitness Identification Act violation dismantled in real time; the sequestration "goose-gander" ruling. This isn't research dressed up as fiction, it's a trial lawyer's muscle memory rendered as narrative, and it gives the book a texture few thriller writers can fake.
The hockey-as-legal-strategy conceit — "forechecking is to law as motions practice is to hockey," "tilting the ice" — is a genuinely original throughline that turns courtroom mechanics into something kinetic and teachable rather than dry. Zenko's voice, mustache and all, gives the reader a wry, self-aware narrator who's honest about his own privilege ("White cops. White prosecutor. White judge... like the fix is in") without turning preachy, and Star Gwiazda is a vivid, specific creation — the wink, the "kraken," the eyelid flutter, the wedding ring she still wears out of professional armor.
The book earns real substance on race and policing without lecturing: the empty-chair irony of an all-white bench trying a Black-led BLM case, the Nifong echo, the bomb threat that turns background tension into a live-wire stake. Where it stumbles is pace — the courtroom procedure sometimes eclipses momentum, and Marcos himself, the person whose life hangs on all this, is thinner than his lawyers. But the specificity of the legal world on the page is the real hook here, and it's earned, not borrowed.
Judged by Marcus Thorne — Thriller · Mystery · Suspense · Commercial Fiction
"Plot is promises kept."
Supporting passages
"Motions practice is to law as forechecking is to hockey. Forechecking is when the wingers, left and right, and the center venture into the offensive zone... and tries to make the other team cough up the puck"
A genuinely original conceit that turns legal strategy into something visceral and specific to the narrator's obsessions.
"She is not sticking to the motion we filed and is riffing... When she gets this amped up, I can almost see an aura of electricity around her crackling."
Star is rendered with precise, affectionate specificity rather than generic 'feisty lawyer' shorthand.
"White cops. White prosecutor. White judge. Like the fix is in as his cousin sings, 'Cuz was framed by the Dur-ham po-po.'"
The racial optics of the courtroom are observed with unsentimental specificity rather than abstraction.
Per-axis rubric scores
Every Booky-winning book is scored across all ten craft axes. The award is given on the top axis (or top two for premium tiers).
Find out what your book does best.
Submit your book today. Get a real, honest, category-specific Booky — or every dollar back.
Submit Your Book → Screen Another Book