Bennett's Wish Love Conquers Hate
by T.M. Arden
MOST CURIOSITY-SPARKING BOOKY
The judge's reasoning
What's in front of me here is mostly front matter and back matter — the dedication, the note for grown-ups, the discussion guide, the Circle of Love activity, the Promise of Kindness pledge — rather than the story itself. Judged on that basis, the book's real strength is what it's building toward: a values-forward resource for adults reading with kids about family diversity, unkind words, and belonging. The "Bennett's Circle of Love" activity is genuinely well-constructed for its purpose, with a scripted grown-up prompt, sentence starters ("Love shines when…"), and explicit permission for non-verbal kids to participate — that's thoughtful classroom-facilitation design, not filler.
The discussion questions move past the usual "how did the character feel" territory into rehearsal: question 3 explicitly gives kids language for confronting unkind comments about families that look different, which is the book doing real work rather than just gesturing at a theme. The "My Promise of Kindness" pledge, with a blank for the child's name and date, is a smart, concrete closer that turns an abstract lesson into something a child can literally sign onto.
As a vehicle for the second book in what's clearly a values-driven series about Amanda Grace and Bennett's family, this apparatus does its job: it hands caregivers and teachers scripted, age-appropriate tools rather than leaving them to improvise a hard conversation. The narrative itself isn't present in this excerpt to judge on plot or prose, so I'm scoring conservatively on those axes and crediting the substance where it's earned — this is a book that knows exactly which reader (and which grown-up) it's for.
Judged by Brooke Hayes — Reader-at-Large · Cross-Genre · Emerging Voices
"Every book is the only book for somebody."
Supporting passages
"What can we say when someone speaks unkindly about a family that looks different from theirs?"
Gives children direct, rehearsable language for a real social situation rather than a vague moral.
"I promise to let love shine like Bennett's family did... because love is stronger than hate."
A signable pledge with a name-and-date line turns the book's theme into a concrete keepsake activity for classrooms and families.
Per-axis rubric scores
Every Booky-winning book is scored across all ten craft axes. The award is given on the top axis (or top two for premium tiers).
Find out what your book does best.
Submit your book today. Get a real, honest, category-specific Booky — or every dollar back.
Submit Your Book → Screen Another Book