Bennett's Wish Love Conquers Hate
by T.M. Arden
MOST CURIOSITY-SPARKING BOOKY
The judge's reasoning
What's in front of me here is mostly front matter and back matter — the dedication, the note for grown-ups, the discussion guide, the Circle of Love activity, the Promise of Kindness pledge — rather than the story itself. Judged on that basis, the book's real strength is what it's building toward: a values-forward resource for adults reading with kids about family diversity, unkind words, and belonging. The "Bennett's Circle of Love" activity is genuinely well-constructed for its purpose, with a scripted grown-up prompt, sentence starters ("Love shines when…"), and explicit permission for non-verbal kids to participate — that's thoughtful classroom-facilitation design, not filler.
The discussion questions move past the usual "how did the character feel" territory into rehearsal: question 3 explicitly gives kids language for confronting unkind comments about families that look different, which is the book doing real work rather than just gesturing at a theme. The "My Promise of Kindness" pledge, with a blank for the child's name and date, is a smart, concrete closer that turns an abstract lesson into something a child can literally sign onto.
As a vehicle for the second book in what's clearly a values-driven series about Amanda Grace and Bennett's family, this apparatus does its job: it hands caregivers and teachers scripted, age-appropriate tools rather than leaving them to improvise a hard conversation. The narrative itself isn't present in this excerpt to judge on plot or prose, so I'm scoring conservatively on those axes and crediting the substance where it's earned — this is a book that knows exactly which reader (and which grown-up) it's for.
Judged by Brooke Hayes — Reader-at-Large · Cross-Genre · Emerging Voices
"Every book is the only book for somebody."
Supporting passages
"What can we say when someone speaks unkindly about a family that looks different from theirs?"
Gives children direct, rehearsable language for a real social situation rather than a vague moral.
"I promise to let love shine like Bennett's family did... because love is stronger than hate."
A signable pledge with a name-and-date line turns the book's theme into a concrete keepsake activity for classrooms and families.
Per-axis rubric scores
Every Booky-winning book is scored across all ten craft axes. The award category comes from the top axis; a second axis at or above 75 appears as secondary recognition.
Find out what your book does best.
Submit your book today. Get a real, honest, category-specific Booky — or every dollar back.
Submit Your Book → Screen Another Book