Alphabet soup
by Sasha Renata
MOST SURPRISING STRUCTURE BOOKY
The judge's reasoning
Renata's manuscript takes its time getting to the good stuff, but when it arrives, it lands. The whole first act is deliberately misdirecting — four "boring" graduates with fake jobs, a café ritual, an alphabet-soup word game that turns out to be a Chekhov's gun for the title itself ("When he started listing them the other three looked very serious... he was disqualified, acronyms were not allowed"). That's a nice bit of structural planting: the throwaway game literally names the organizations that will run the plot.
The real payoff is the Harry Snell reveal. Cynthia's flicker of recognition ("she seemed to remember the package for real") is planted early and pays off exactly when it should — right as John, on the other end of a phone line, notices "the flap of silicone face mask loose" on the man everyone assumed was the director. That's a legitimate thriller beat: a twist seeded quietly, then confirmed through someone else's eyes, which is a smarter delivery mechanism than most first-time thriller writers manage.
The tradecraft world-building backs this up with real specificity — the tire-sweeping devices, the four-person biometric lock on the Nissan, the rotating entrance points, the bubble-couch elevator into the bunker. These details aren't just decorative; they set up the very rules (four-or-nothing, code requirements) that get stress-tested when Paul shows up alone and armed. The book knows its own rules well enough to break them for tension.
The prose needs a serious copyedit pass, and the dialogue leans heavily on characters explaining the plot to each other. But the bones — a twist you don't see coming but believe once John notices that loose mask — are genuinely there.
Judged by Marcus Thorne — Thriller · Mystery · Suspense · Commercial Fiction
"Plot is promises kept."
Supporting passages
"It was as if Harry sensed Johns eyes on him and felt for the side of his face and noticed the flap of silicone face mask loose."
The seeded impostor twist pays off through a witness's eyes rather than a clumsy narrator reveal — a legitimately effective thriller mechanic.
"Around the back was a hidden entrance that appeared to be just a wall but opened after a code was input via a special phone application that they all had."
The tradecraft — sweepers, rotating entrances, four-person biometric locks — is specific enough to feel like real operational logic, not window dressing.
"When he started listing them the other three looked very serious and said in unison that he was disqualified, acronyms were not allowed."
A throwaway café game that doubles as the title's thesis statement — a clean, memorable hook mechanism.
Per-axis rubric scores
Every Booky-winning book is scored across all ten craft axes. The award is given on the top axis (or top two for premium tiers).
Find out what your book does best.
Submit your book today. Get a real, honest, category-specific Booky — or every dollar back.
Submit Your Book → Screen Another Book