Booky Awards Winner

Allison: A Poetic Diary

by Mickey Helms


MOST EARNED ENDING BOOKY
Allison: A Poetic Diary cover

The judge's reasoning


Allison: A Poetic Diary is a short, controlled experiment in form, and it knows exactly what it is doing. The diary-in-verse conceit is announced in the preface with disarming modesty ("I was never very good with paragraphs or essays"), and the book spends twenty-one entries letting that plain, clipped voice do its quiet work.

The structure is the book's real achievement. Dated entries from June to July 1981 build a patient escalation: the newspaper-reading regular who "looked up at the right moment," the surveillance ("I had to see her during the day / Her patterns"), the makeover, the invented persona. The most chilling device is the invented persona. "William" starts as a costume and ends as an alibi, a name the narrator can hand every terrible act to. Watch how the pronouns drift: "I" confesses in the early entries, then "William" takes over ("William made sure Allison was taken care of") until the narrator can say "He could come to her rescue" about a man who is himself.

The repetition is deliberate and pays off. "She will be mine" becomes "She will be ours," and the dutiful courtship details (Japanese dinner, chopsticks used "like scissors," the For Your Eyes Only date) sit beside the narrator's cheerfully flat reporting, so the dread builds from the gap between a charming date and a hunter's field notes. The fortune cookie, "There is a surprise in your future," followed by "Oh yes there is," is dark comedy that lands precisely.

The final entry is stripped of ornament, and that restraint lets the ending hit as hard as it does. The closing line, "Such a shame / We will miss Allison," is as chilling as the book can make it.

A reader of true-crime-adjacent psychological horror, or anyone who likes a verse form bent to unsettling ends, will find a lean, memorable book here.

Brooke Hayes

Judged by Brooke Hayes — Reader-at-Large · Cross-Genre · Emerging Voices

"Every book is the only book for somebody."

Supporting passages


Plot & Structure
"Allison only sees me when I want her to see me"

A single line establishes the narrator's control and the asymmetry that the escalating entries then exploit.

Characterization
"To Allison, I was William / A man of stature / Of sophistication / She didn't need to know me / She only needed to know William"

The invented persona is the book's psychological engine, showing a narrator who hides behind a name and later lets that name carry his violence.

Plot & Structure
"Hers said "There is a surprise in your future" Of yes there is"

A small domestic moment doubles as black-comic foreshadowing, the kind of buried payoff the book does best.

Per-axis rubric scores


Every Booky-winning book is scored across all ten craft axes. The award category comes from the top axis; a second axis at or above 75 appears as secondary recognition.

Prose & Style
78
Characterization SECONDARY RECOGNITION
80
Dialogue
66
Plot & Structure AWARDED
80
World-Building
72
Originality
78
Emotional Resonance
77
Theme & Substance
76
Genre Execution
80
Marketability & Hook
76

Find out what your book does best.

Submit your book today. Get a real, honest, category-specific Booky — or every dollar back.

Submit Your Book → Screen Another Book