Alfheim
by Gary A Nilsen
MOST HARD-WON HOPE BOOKY
The judge's reasoning
Nilsen's opening chapters spend far longer in the mundane misery of Ossipee High than in Alfheim itself, and that's the right choice — because Timothy Brennan's despair is rendered with a specificity that earns the reader's investment before any fae queen shows up. The bird revival scene is genuinely well-placed: the electricity-through-veins sensation, the 'human defibrillator' image, gives us a magic system seeded quietly inside a story that otherwise reads like contemporary YA realism, and it works because we've already spent chapters believing in Timothy's ordinary, grinding unhappiness.
The uncle Jim material is the strongest writing in this excerpt. The line 'So she died. So much for drugs' is a genuinely ugly, believable thing for a grieving, resentful man to say to a grieving, ticcing teenager, and Timothy's inability to argue against it — 'There were probably a thousand things wrong with that argument, but he saw none of them' — is a sharp, true observation about how emotional abuse actually lands. The bridge scene that closes this excerpt, with Timothy's calm, almost administrative internal accounting of suicide ('A simple breath to let the water into his lungs? Not so bad'), avoids melodrama in favor of something quieter and more clinical, which is much harder to pull off and much more devastating.
The fantasy machinery — Cadwaladr, Seumais, the watching fae girl in the trees — is still assembling itself at this point, more promise than delivery, but the human stakes underneath it are already doing real work.
Judged by Dr. Aiyana Reyes — Science Fiction · Fantasy · Horror · Speculative
"A world earns belief one detail at a time."
Supporting passages
"A simple breath to let the water into his lungs? Not so bad."
The chilling flatness of this internal register captures depression's compulsion more honestly than a more dramatic phrasing would.
"You know what drugs do? They fog up your head. Did you ever think that maybe when your mother got sick, you might have done something about it?"
Jim's cruelty is specific and plausible rather than cartoonish, giving the antagonist real weight.
Per-axis rubric scores
Every Booky-winning book is scored across all ten craft axes. The award is given on the top axis (or top two for premium tiers).
Find out what your book does best.
Submit your book today. Get a real, honest, category-specific Booky — or every dollar back.
Submit Your Book → Screen Another Book